Allstate vs Esurance

Allstate Car Insurance vs Esurance Car InsuranceAllstate vs Esurance, both are recognizable car insurance companies.

If you find yourself having to choose between them, here are the facts (and then be sure to use the free tool for comparing quotes for car insurance!)

Enter your zip in above to get started comparing free online car insurance quotes!

Update: Esurance is now owned by Allstate!

Allstate and Esurance Histories

Allstate was founded in 1931 by Sears, Roebuck and Co. It is the second largest personal lines insurer in the U.S. and sponsors many sporting events. Allstate became a publicly traded company in 1993.

Esurance is a San Francisco based, online insurance company that was founded in 1998.

It is an environmentally friendly company and has partnered with several environmental organizations. Esurance was acquired by White Mountains Insurance Group in 2000.

Allstate Service vs Esurance Service

Because Allstate has been around for so long it offers 13 lines of insurance including . . .

  • Auto insurance
  • Home insurance
  • Life and Health insurance
  • Motorcycle insurance
  • Policies for teens with discount programs for good students.
  • Business insurance
  • Banking services

Esurance offers. . .

  • Auto insurance
  • Motorcycle insurance
  • Home insurance
  • Renters insurance

Esurance also allows you to compare rates from other companies on their website and choose the one you prefer including. . .

  • Life and health insurance
  • Pet insurance
  • Insurance for boats and other vehicles

Esurance offers insurance in 30 states while Allstate offers insurance in 49 states. Esurance uses a 3 step process online that allows you to print your insurance policy at home instantly, while Allstate, being a traditional insurance company delivers it by mail except in certain states.

Allstate has 24 hour claim service, online claim filing and a downloadable worksheet to keep track of your claim. Esurance also offers 24 hour service and online claim filing as well as an online E-star facility where you can see photos and information of your car as it is being repaired.

General Opinions

As far as Allstate vs Esurance, both companies have their share of complaints against them. Allstate has a higher rating from J.D. Power than Esurance, but has been ranked by the American Association of Justice as the number #1 worst ensurer in the U.S.

General opinion is that Allstate offers a much more varied selection of services, but Esurance is quicker, more convenient and more efficient. It seems to depend on which of these qualities is more important to the customer.

Comparing Quotes

Be sure to compare car insurance quotes from Allstate, Esurance, and many other companies. Enter your zip to start now!

Copyright © 2014 · All Rights Reserved · Car Insurance Comparison · About Us · Privacy Policy · Contact Us · Site Map · Resources