The battle between Progressive and Farmers insurance is one of progressivism versus conservatism, and not necessarily in a political way. Read on to decide for yourself who wins the battle of Farmers vs Progressive auto insurance and then be sure to enter your zip in for a free car insurance comparison!
Both of the companies have been well-established since the 20’s and 30’s in the United States, but Progressive went through a massive makeover in the late 90’s.
This can be reflected in their consistent marketing campaigns, which sport memorable characters such as the overenthusiastic employee, “Flo”, who paints the company in a friendly and liberal light (click to read more about the girl in the Progressive car insurance commercials: Flo).
This was reflected when Progressive decided to withdraw all of their commercials from FOX news channel for a time, when host Glenn Beck decided to make negative comments about President Barrack Obama.
Farmers has been relatively quiet, and has not started any major advertising campaigns. The inheritance factor of Farmers as an insurance company provides a steady flow of new clients. Grandfathers and fathers pass the insurance company onto their children.
But which company truly provides better insurance and better service? Which company has a higher customer satisfaction rate?
Progressive is generally overwhelmingly favored by customers and critics. Progressive has won a consistent amount of awards ever since their 90’s makeover, and have improved their customer satisfaction rates tenfold. Their website shows a list of their competitors, giving honest quotes as a way to help promote customer trust and relationships.
They even email their customers automatically when they could be getting a better deal at another company, and offer a policy builder to customize a policy for as low as ten dollars a month ($120 dollars a year).
Farmers has comparatively higher prices, making Progressive the cheapest among insurance companies. Progressive has a higher rated concierge claim service, and customer satisfaction is much, much higher. Comparatively, Farmers remains the dominant insurance company in the southern half of the United States, and is even cheaper in places like Texas, considering the higher price of Progressive’s auto insurance.
Progressive boasts that it offers the best service for the lowest price, which is a common claim amongst companies, of course. Progressive fulfills this promise, however, and critics agree that it is one of the best insurance companies for auto insurance on the market.
Farmers still has better home and life insurance policies, however. Progressive soars above Farmers in the auto insurance department. Farmers is a better choice for those looking for home and life insurance policies.
Consumer Reports gave Progressive the 2008 “Most Trusted” award, which is rare for an insurance company. It won amongst hundreds of other businesses, beating out Legalzoom.com as the most trusted company in America.
Here are a list of cities with prices that are significantly lower for either company’s policy:
- Seattle – Progressive (A massive average saving of $600 per year! Wow!)
- Austin – Progressive (Surprisingly, minimal savings of about $75/year)
- Houston – Progressive (Surprise, $300-400 savings per year!)
- Dallas – Farmers (For some reason, Farmers is a lot cheaper in this city)
- New York – Farmers (Farmers remains the king in NYC)
- Portland – Progressive
- Chicago – Progressive
- Boston – Progressive
- Charleston – Progressive (Savings of over $500 a year. I was hugely surprised by this one, as the trend shows that southern cities typically favor Farmers over other insurance companies)
Do your own comparison of Farmers and Progressive along with many other companies! To get car insurance quotes from many top companies like Progressive and Farmers then enter your zip in and start comparing car insurance quotes now!