Zaneta Wood, Ed.S. has over 15 years of experience in research and technical writing bringing a keen understanding of data analysis and information synthesis to reach a wide variety of audiences. She studied adult education and instructional technology at Appalachian State University as well as technical and professional communication at East Carolina University. Zaneta has prepared technical p...

Full Bio →

Written by

Joel Ohman is the CEO of a private equity backed digital media company. He is a CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™, author, angel investor, and serial entrepreneur who loves creating new things, whether books or businesses. He has also previously served as the founder and resident CFP® of a national insurance agency, Real Time Health Quotes. He has an MBA from the University of South Florida. Jo...

Full Bio →

Reviewed by Joel Ohman
Founder & CFP®

UPDATED: Aug 15, 2020

Advertiser Disclosure

It’s all about you. We want to help you make the right coverage choices.

Advertiser Disclosure: We strive to help you make confident insurance decisions. Comparison shopping should be easy. We partner with top insurance providers. This doesn’t influence our content. Our opinions are our own.

Editorial Guidelines: We are a free online resource for anyone interested in learning more about auto insurance. Our goal is to be an objective, third-party resource for everything auto insurance related. We update our site regularly, and all content is reviewed by auto insurance experts.

The below car insurance comparison chart shows the top US car insurance companies to compare side by side with easy to compare statistics like the year the company was founded, the company’s AM Best financial strength rating, US market share, as well as a link to a full car insurance company review. Be sure to review our guide to the best car insurance companies and then do a car insurance comparison online with free rate quotes.

COMPANY
NAME
YEAR FOUNDED AM BEST RATING MARKET SHARE COMPANY
REVIEW
Allstate
1931
A+
11%
American Family
1927
A
2%
Farmers
1928
A
5%
Geico
1936
A++
7%
Geico Car Insurance Review
Liberty Mutual
1912
A
3%
Nationwide
1925
A+
5%
Progressive
1937
A+
7%
State Farm
1922
A++
18%

Sources: A.M. Best, NAIC, Progressive, Insurance Information Institute

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap car insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

For a full listing of companies be sure to visit the car insurance companies page and then be sure to enter your ZIP code into the FREE tool to do a free personalized online car insurance comparison – the more quotes you compare the more chances you have to find cheap rates on car insurance!

How are car insurance companies ranked?

  • There are several companies that rank and rate insurance companies and all that data should be considered when making your car insurance choice
  • Customer ratings deal with how a company treats their customers
  • Financial ratings concern the stability of the company and their ability to pay claims

Car insurance companies are ranked in a number of different ways from customer ratings to rankings by professional companies based on customer surveys and/or financial ratings.

When choosing an auto insurance company, you should consider all types of ratings before you decide.

Get car insurance quotes from several companies with just a zip code now!

A financially secure company, for example, doesn’t necessarily have the best customer service.

Read on to learn some of the things that you should consider when looking at rankings for insurance companies.

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap car insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Customer Rankings

You can find customer rankings of auto insurance companies in a variety of different places.

  • Your first stop should be your state’s Department of Insurance. An insurance company’s rating in one state can be very different than their rating in another state. Focus on ratings for your state and then check neighboring states if the results are too close for you to make a decision based on this information.
  • JD Power and Associates is an excellent source for finding insurance company ratings. The information that JD Power provides is entirely based on consumer ratings and not on their own experiences with an insurance company.
  • In addition to these professional ranking sources, you can look for websites that focus on offering reviews and rankings, like Consumer Reports. It is important that you choose independent sites that are not funded or that do not represent any auto insurance companies.
  • You can also find forums and such that don’t necessarily rank insurance companies but simply discuss customers’ personal experiences as well as give those with questions a place to ask them without getting the “company line” that they would receive if they called an insurance company directly.

When you use the Department of Insurance to check a company’s rating, you are going to see a rating based on complaints. These complaints will usually be listed per 1,000 customers. For example, you might see 20 complaints per 1,000 customers.

When using these sites, you do need to use some caution as people are more likely to complain than they are to compliment. When you use a professional source, people from all different situations complete surveys.

You can find rankings based on pretty much any aspect that you find important such as cost, claim processing speed, customer service, and customer satisfaction and so on.

JD Power has an annual claims study that they conduct and then they rank companies based on those results.

You can find sites that offer in depth reviews about insurance companies based on personal experience or in-depth research that allows them to give an accurate review of each company that they are talking about.

When you visit an opinion based site, such as a forum, people are compelled to write something because they are passionate about the subject. This does not always lead to the most subjective of information and should be treated as such.

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap car insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Financial Rankings

Another way that insurance companies are ranked is by their financial stability. This type of ranking is not based on how well a company does with customer service issues or how quickly they pay a claim or other concerns of that nature.

Instead, this type of ranking is based solely on an insurance company’s ability to pay insurance claims.

Companies like AM Best and Standard & Poor’s focus on this aspect.

In addition to ranking a company based on their ability to pay claims, these companies will also offer a projection of future stability based on past performance in conjunction with their current performance.

These companies are not funded by insurance companies and will give an honest assessment of a company’s financial ability to pay.

You can access the information from either of these companies online, however, you will need to have the name of an insurance company in mind in order to find the information that you want.

Neither of these sites offers a ranking in order of stability or anything like that.

Getting the Best Insurance

Getting the best insurance should start with an auto insurance quote. If you start by getting a quote, your research of different companies will go more smoothly.

Progressive, for example, gets excellent consumer ratings, but they may not necessarily have the most affordable auto insurance available.

You will want to choose a high-ranking company, but you don’t want to pay a fortune for your coverage. Using the free online car insurance quotes tool is the fastest way to achieve this goal.

Start with a zip code and find out which car insurance rates and companies fit your needs now!

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap car insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Finding the Best Companies for Car Insurance

Find the best car insurance for you by (1) visiting third-party review sites, (2) looking at financial ratings, and (3) comparing quotes from multiple companies.

  • The best car insurance company will depend on personal factors
  • Finding the best car insurance company for you takes research
  • Customer service and financial stability are important factors when choosing a provider

Everyone has his or her own preference which is not likely to change unless there’s a major reason to do so.

The fact is, car insurance is a very personal thing for most people.

It’s not uncommon for an individual driver to stick with the same car insurance company throughout his entire life, especially if he’s never had any difficulties with them.

You can see online car insurance rates right now by entering your ZIP code below!

What should I be looking for in a car insurance company?

Determining which car insurance companies are the best requires a serious evaluation of your needs and desires.

 For example, every insurance provider licensed to do business in your state will provide the legally required minimum coverage at a price comparable to their competitors.

But you must ask yourself whether or not you require more coverage than simply the state minimums. If you do, you’ll find that’s where most of the price differences begin to show up.

In terms of coverage, you should be looking for a company that will cover your needs at a price you can afford.

What about customer service?

Next to coverage and the bottom-line price, one of the other important factors to consider is customer service.

Hopefully, you never need to make a car insurance claim, but if you do, customer service turns out to be everything.

The last thing you need during the stress of an accident is to call your insurance company and be put on hold for an hour.

Look for a company that is responsive to your needs not only in a timely manner, but also with a friendly, courteous, and caring attitude.

A good place to investigate customer service is through online car insurance ratings sites such as Moody’s or Weiss Ratings.

Many of these sites rate companies according to several criteria, including customer satisfaction.

Just be careful of comparison websites who glean their information from user forums or other similar resources.

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap car insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap car insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Should I worry about financial stability?

In most cases, the financial stability of an insurance company will never come into play. However, that’s not to say it’s never a factor.

There are some insurance companies who are financially unstable and may present a problem down the road.

The quickest and easiest way to find out where your insurance company stands is to visit the websites of some of the leading financial services rating companies.

Two examples of these types of companies are A.M. Best and Standard & Poor’s.

These companies rate the financial strength and future outlook of insurance companies, banks, and other financial institutions, based solely on hard numbers and forecasts by financial experts.

Is there anything else I need to know?

At the end of the day, the best insurance companies are the ones who can provide you the appropriate coverage, customer satisfaction, and future stability you need.

Finding these companies requires that you do your homework before making a decision.

So ask friends and family, search online, and find out as much information as you can. Doing so will increase your chances of finding the right car insurance company for you.

Get car insurance quotes from America’s best auto insurance companies by entering your ZIP code right now!

Most Reputable Companies for Car Insurance

Three of the most reputable car insurance companies in the US are Geico, Nationwide, and Liberty Mutual. Compare quotes below to reduce your bill by up to 20%.

  • Geico provides insurance in all 50 states, and the company has been around for more than 70 years
  • Nationwide started out offering auto insurance to Ohio farmers and ranchers in 1926, and has grown to offer insurance nationwide to drivers of all professions
  • Liberty Mutual began as a workers compensation insurance company in 1912

When looking for car insurance, it is a good idea to shop around for the best rates and coverage. You can request price quotes from several companies using an online insurance quote comparison website.

Going with the absolute cheapest car insurance quote isn’t always the best idea. You also want to make sure that the car insurance company is reputable.

Here are 10 of the most reputable insurance companies, based on customer ratings and the Insurance Information Institute. Companies are listed in no particular order.

Enter your ZIP code above and we will help you find insurance from the most reputable car insurance companies.

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap car insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Geico

Geico provides insurance in all 50 states, and the company has been around for more than 70 years. Geico ranks very high in response and repair, benefits and discounts, policy flexibility, customer service and claims timeliness.

Geico offers several discounts to its policyholders, including good driver, good student, anti-theft device, multiple-vehicle, multiple-line, corporate loyalty, loyalty, and advanced safety features car insurance discounts.

Geico is one of the most affordable insurance companies because they operate through a non-agent model, which allows for policyholders who file claims and inquiries by phone and online, reducing overhead costs.

Progressive

Progressive has been a leader in the industry for more than 70 years. The company consistently receives top marks for its response, repair, and timeliness for customer service and claims.

Progressive policyholders can receive discounts such as good student, corporate affiliate, loyalty, advanced safety features, low-mileage, multiple-vehicle, anti-theft device, full payment and automatic payment discounts.

We have a list and more detailed explanation of Progressive car insurance discounts.

Progressive stands out because of its concierge level of claims service and its immediate response vehicles, which provide quick and easy claims services.

Esurance

Esurance does not have the 70 years of experience that some other car insurance companies have, but the company has quickly made a name for itself in the industry since it was launched in December 1994.

Aside from its hassle-free policy-purchasing process and expedited claims processing, the company is known for its environmental initiatives.

Esurance consciously limits its paper consumption and takes steps to mitigate the effects of carbon dioxide pollution. We have a full list of Esurance car insurance discounts, check it out to make a more informed decision when choosing which car insurance companies to go with.

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap car insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company

Nationwide started out offering auto insurance to Ohio farmers and ranchers in 1926, and has grown to offer insurance nationwide to drivers of all professions.

The company receives top marks for customer service and claims timeliness, and stands out for its 100 percent guarantees on repairs for the life of the policyholder’s car.

Policyholders can take advantage of many discounts, including anti-theft device, advanced safety features, loyalty, good driver, good student, multiple-line, multiple-vehicle, and corporate affiliate discounts.

See the car insurance coverage and deductible options Nationwide offers.

State Farm Car Insurance Company

State Farm is another insurance company that started by offering auto insurance to a limited pool of farmer policyholders in 1922.

The company went on to expand its offerings to policyholders of all sorts and has become a large and reputable company.

The company consistently receives good marks in response and repair, customer service and claims timeliness, policy flexibility, benefits, and discounts. For more information on this company see our State Farm car insurance review.

Liberty Mutual Car Insurance Company

Liberty Mutual began as a workers compensation insurance company in 1912. The company then branched out to offer auto insurance in 1914.

The company is well known for its policy features including cracked windshield repair and Total Liberty Care Facilities to take care of repairs quickly.

While the company receives high marks for its policy offerings, its customer service is lacking. To find out more about this company head over to our Liberty Mutual car insurance review.

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap car insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Allstate Car Insurance Company

Allstate was founded in 1931 and started the first auto insurance company that offered policies by direct mail. The company also provided policies through the Sears catalog.

Allstate rates well among companies for their policy flexibility, but the company’s timeliness for customer service and claims misses the mark sometimes.

The company does stand out among the many insurance providers by offering deductible discounts for each year that the policyholder goes without any accidents. There are a lot of benefits for choosing Allstate car insurance.

USAA Insurance Group

United Services Automobile Association (USAA) started out in 1922 by offering automobile insurance to U.S. Army officers. At the time, this group had a difficult time receiving automobile insurance because the group was viewed as a high risk.

Today, USAA offers insurance policies to all Armed Forces members and those who served in the U.S. Armed Forces honorably.

The policies are also available to their immediate families. USAA stands out because of its extensive discounts and benefits. Read the list of USAA discounts to find out which ones you would qualify for.

Farmers Insurance Group

Farmers Insurance was founded in 1928 to offer lower insurance premiums to farmers and ranchers. The company has since expanded its customer base and has become the third most popular provider of private passenger automobile insurance in the United States.

Today, the company is reputable for its good driver discounts and customized policies. They have also become famous for their Farmers fast quote service.

AAA

American Automobile Association (AAA) is a very popular not-for-profit organization that offers a wide range of services, including automobile insurance.

The insurance is not comprehensive, but it does provide savings by allowing members services such as towing and roadside assistance from their primary automobile insurance policies.

Aside from the excellent roadside assistance and AAA-approved automobile repair facilities, membership offers many additional benefits such as discounts for travel and retail. For a better understanding of how AAA works, read our AAA review for car insurance.

There are many reputable automobile insurance companies and policies to choose from, but the only way to find the policy that is best for you is to do some price shopping.

Use our car insurance comparison tool and enter your ZIP code to find the best car insurance for your needs.

Places to Compare Car Insurance Companies

  • When choosing an insurance provider, make sure you check out a variety of factors
  • Comparing several companies will help you to find the best deal on insurance coverage
  • Remember that price is not the only factor to consider when choosing an insurance policy

Choosing the right auto insurance provider is not easy. Customers need to consider the company’s reputation and financial strength, as well as its location, services, and prices.

Each company uses a different formula to assign risk and calculate your rates.

Insurance plans and premiums may also vary by state.

The best way to find a reliable car insurance provider is to enter your ZIP code in our car insurance comparison tool, and you will receive a comparison of car insurance quotes.

Compare Car Insurance Companies Online

There are hundreds of insurance companies to choose from. They key to comparison shopping is to identify your individual needs.

What types of car insurance coverage do you need? How much insurance can you afford to buy?

Know that some cars are more expensive to insure than others. If you have a sports vehicle, you will pay more on coverage than drivers with standard cars.

Insurance rates may also differ from one company to the next.

Many drivers are surprised to find out that some auto insurance carriers offer similar policies at rates that vary drastically.

Make sure you look for an auto insurance company that sells competitively priced policies featuring extensive coverage.

Open your favorite browser and search for a reputable insurance website. Many sites allow drivers to compare auto insurance quotes from local and national companies.

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Car Insurance Provider

If you find a car insurance policy that fits both your needs and your budget, contact the company you are interested in.

Ask them relevant questions related to their products and services.

  • Who are their top clients?
  • How long have they been in business?
  • Do they offer online support?
  • Are they able to handle claims in a timely manner?

Check their industry ratings, as well as their financial strength, customer service, billing and payment options, technical help, email support, and rates.

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap car insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Financial Strength

Make sure you always check the company’s financial ratings.

A.M Best, Standard and Poor’s, Fitch, and Moody’s evaluate the financial strength of various insurance companies.

These independent agencies conduct financial analyses of local and national insurers, and their reports are available online.

Other companies, such as J.D. Power Ratings, collect data from individual policyholders nationwide and rate them according to coverage options, premiums, customer service and other criteria.

Licensing

Some insurers are not licensed to operate in all states.

Before you make a decision, visit your state’s insurance department to see which car insurance providers are licensed to do business in your area.

Reputation

Look for insurers with a good reputation. A well-established company understands the complexity of the insurance business and knows how to handle a difficult situation.

The Internet is an excellent resource for finding customer reviews and unbiased opinions about specific insurance companies.

Talking with other policyholders and reading reviews can help you find out more about the companies in question.

Another great way to identify reliable insurance providers is to contact local auto repair shops and ask for their recommendations.

They know which companies can be trusted and which insurers are looking for ways to cut costs at the expense of their own customers.

Make sure you look for auto insurance companies that have only a few complaints filed against them.

Cheaper Is Not Always Better

Some companies sell policies that sound too good to be true. While you might be tempted to buy a cheap auto insurance policy, choose one that offers reasonable car insurance rates.

If you buy a more expensive car insurance plan, you can reduce costs later.

Many companies offer special prices and discounts to customers who buy coverage through their websites.

Some insurers also provide live chat, 24/7 customer service, quote comparison tools, and online quote forms.

The best car insurance company for you is one that offers competitively priced products and has a record of outstanding customer service.

Make sure you choose an insurance carrier that offers flexible policies with a wide range of options.

Enter your ZIP code now and we can help you find the best car insurance by sending you multiple car insurance quotes.

Why should I compare car insurance?

  • Compare prices, financial stability, and reputation of any potential providers
  • Most companies offer similar discounts but some do not offer any
  • High-risk drivers will probably have to do more research to obtain a good deal on insurance
  • Take your time when comparing companies to make sure you get the best deal possible

There are many reasons why you should compare auto insurance. Purchasing insurance for all vehicles in your household is not only important but also required in most areas of the country.

Many insurance providers compete to have your business which is why it can be tough when choosing a provider.

Not all auto insurance companies are created equal, and not all of them provide the same products.

In order for you to end up with a quality company that will fulfill all of your insurance needs, you should take the time and energy to look more closely at a few and compare key points.

Start your comparison of auto insurance rates by entering your ZIP code in the Free quote box above!

Car Insurance Rates Comparison

The rate quote is one of the biggest ways that drivers compare policies. Car insurance can be a big expense every year or month, depending on how often you pay your policy.

Finding the cheapest policy is the goal of many drivers, and saving money is the main reason to compare rates.

You can compare rate quotes a number of ways. If you have time and prefer face-to-face interaction, making an appointment at a few local insurance offices may be the way to go. This is especially true if you do not have much understanding about insurance and how it works.

When you visit different agents, you will be able to sit down with them and evaluate your insurance needs. This includes determining what is the best coverage for the vehicle you drive, how many people you are insuring, and what you deductible you can afford.

After collecting the necessary information, the agent can then run it through the system and come up with a quote. The majority of offices will do this at no charge to you. After you visit a few offices, you can choose one based on policy price alone.

A quicker way to get free instant quotes is through the Internet.

You can visit each company’s website separately or you can go to one site that provides quotes for multiple insurance companies. The latter method is the most expedient, as you only have to enter all the pertinent information once.

Rates may vary a bit between each insurance company but ultimately your premium will be based off information provided by you about your vehicle and your driving history.

If your driving record is less than stellar and/or you drive a fast luxury vehicle, you can spend hours trying to find a low insurance rate without success. Visit the Insurance Information Institute for more details on how the policy rate is determined.

Although policy price may be a big factor in choosing an insurance company, there are other things that are important to compare as well. You may decide that paying a bit more for a policy with a higher quality company is worth it.

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap car insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Financial Stability

Another factor that is important is financial stability.

How a car insurance company rates financially should tie into your decision when comparing different companies.

The financial rating and outlook for the future can reveal a lot about an insurance provider. Once you have narrowed your choice of providers down to three or four, visit a site such as A.M. Best and look each of the companies up.

You will be presented with a wealth of information. The financial strength rating will show the rating, the financial size category, the company’s outlook, action, and effective date. Look for a company with a high rating, such as A- and better.

You will also see the issuer credit rating of the company, which gives a good idea of the ability of the company to meet its financial obligations, including both present and future claims. You will see a long-term rating, outlook, and action. Look for a company whose outlook is stable.

Insurance Company Reputation

The reputation of the company you are researching is important as well. There are some insurance companies that are a bit shadier than others or that have many complaints against them.

Comparing certain aspects of every insurance company’s reputation with its customers will help you make the right decision for your auto insurance needs.

A great source to tap into when you are comparing companies is the insurance department in your state. Most drivers don’t have the contact information of their local department, but it can easily be found through the National Association of Insurance Commissioners.

The state department can also provide a wealth of information about the insurance providers in your area.

First, check to make sure each of the companies you are considering is licensed and registered to provide insurance in your state, as not all companies are. Secondly, ask about any criticisms or compliments that may have been made against any of the companies.

Listen closely for complaints about the claims process, as this is where most insurance companies make their money.

You may think that because you pay your premium every month, you will be treated fairly in the event you ever have to submit a claim. Unfortunately, insurance companies pad their bottom line by skimping on claim payments.

Some companies will offer a lower settlement than is right or fair, and others will fight paying the claim at all.

Any criticisms against how a company handles claims is a red flag, and you should strongly consider choosing a different company.

Another source for complaints is the Better Business Bureau. You can enter your zip code and then search for car insurance companies in your local area. Whether the company is accredited by the Better Business Bureau or not, it will still list how many, if any, complaints have been made.

The BBB will break down the complaints into different categories, showing the total number of complaints in regards the following:

  • Billing and collecting
  • Sales and advertising
  • Problems with service or products
  • Warranty and guarantee issues
  • Delivery issues

It also shows how many were closed complaints, which means that the company did its best to resolve the problems.

Discounts Offered

Once you have compared auto insurance companies based on the main issues, you can further compare them. An additional comparison is to see what types of discounts are offered by each provider.

Although you are quoted a certain rate, take advantage of any discounts offered by any of the companies which will save you additional money.

Many of insurance companies today offer similar discounts. However,  some do not offer any while some offer discounts that other providers do not. Ask a representative or your agent if you are eligible for any discounts they offer. You never know how much you could save!

High-Risk Drivers

One group of drivers that may have to do a more thorough search for car insurance is high-risk drivers.

If you are going through the normal channels to find an insurance policy but you have a terrible driving record and/or have had your license suspended, there’s a good chance that many insurance companies will choose not to insure you.

Because having car insurance is required for most drivers, you will eventually find a policy, but you may have to get creative. There are some insurance companies that tailor specifically to drivers that are considered high risk.

The best way to find and compare these companies is to do a general search for high-risk auto insurance which will then direct you to their websites.

When you are comparing insurance policies for high-risk drivers, prepare to see very high rates. The only way these companies are able to offer you a policy is to have you pay a much higher premium so that their risk is somewhat lowered.

In the event that these high-risk or non-standard companies choose not to insure you, contact your state insurance department to see what your state government offers in terms of insurance.

Be Selective

The main reason you want to compare different aspects of auto insurance is that each company can vary greatly. A good company for your friend may not be a good fit for you.

It will take you a little more time to check into the companies, but fortunately, the Internet makes it easier. Most of the information you need is right at your fingertips and can be found at all times of the day. Taking the time to do your research will ultimately save you from frustrations in the future.

If you choose a company and find that it is not meeting your insurance needs the way you were hoping, don’t hesitate to do another comparison search!

There is nothing wrong with changing car insurance companies, as long as you don’t have a gap in coverage. Find the right provider and after you sign the policy, your new agent can cancel your other one.

It is quick and easy to compare auto insurance rates by filling your ZIP code in the FREE quote box provided below!