Best Lancaster, OH Car Insurance in 2025

Car insurance in Lancaster, OH averages $236 a month. Lancaster, Ohio car insurance requirements are 25/50/25, but you might need full coverage insurance if your car is financed. To find cheap Lancaster car insurance rates, compare quotes from the top car insurance companies in Lancaster, OH.

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

By clicking, you agree to our Terms of Use

Nationwide State Farm Allstate
AllstateState FarmNationwideLiberty MutualFarmers Insurance
Justin Wright

Licensed Insurance Agent

Justin Wright has been a licensed insurance broker for over 9 years. After graduating from Southeastern Seminary with a Masters in Philosophy, Justin started his career as a professor, teaching Philosophy and Ethics. Later, Justin obtained both his Property & Casualty license and his Life and Health license and began working for State Farm and Allstate. In 2020, Justin began working as an i...

Written by
Justin Wright
Brandon Frady

Licensed Insurance Agent

Brandon Frady has been a licensed insurance agent and insurance office manager since 2018. He has experience in ventures from retail to finance, working positions from cashier to management, but it wasn’t until Brandon started working in the insurance industry that he truly felt at home in his career. In his day-to-day interactions, he aims to live out his business philosophy in how he treats hi...

Reviewed by
Brandon Frady

Updated December 2025

Here's What You Need to Know

  • The cheapest car insurance company in Lancaster for teen drivers is American Family
  • The cheapest car insurance company in Lancaster is American Family
  • Average car insurance rates in Lancaster, OH are $2,834/year

If you need to buy Lancaster, Ohio car insurance, the options can be confusing. Everything you need to know about car insurance in Lancaster, OH is right here.

You’ll find Lancaster car insurance rates, the cheapest Lancaster, OH car insurance companies, and information on Ohio car insurance laws. You can also compare Lancaster, Ohio car insurance rates to Dayton car insurance rates, Columbus car insurance rates, and Lorain car insurance rates.

Ready to find affordable Lancaster, OH car insurance today? Enter your ZIP code for fast, free Lancaster car insurance quotes.

Cheapest Lancaster, OH Car Insurance Rates By Age, Gender, and Marital Status

How do age, gender, and marital status affect Lancaster, OH car insurance rates? Every Lancaster, Ohio car insurance company weighs these factors differently, so check out the comparison rates.

Annual Car Insurance Rates by Age, Gender, and Marital Status in Lancaster, Ohio

Insurance Company Married 35-Year-Old Female Married 35-Year-Old Male Married 60-Year-Old Female Married 60-Year-Old Male Single 17-Year-Old Female Single 17-Year-Old Male Single 25-Year-Old Female Single 25-Year-Old Male
Allstate $2,079 $2,070 $1,874 $2,003 $5,783 $6,626 $2,185 $2,334
American Family $967 $1,005 $882 $887 $2,971 $3,231 $1,195 $1,260
Farmers $1,827 $1,823 $1,610 $1,699 $8,110 $8,420 $2,048 $2,137
Geico $1,334 $1,296 $1,251 $1,264 $3,589 $3,339 $1,483 $1,255
Liberty Mutual $2,059 $2,248 $1,585 $1,926 $10,674 $12,059 $2,195 $2,400
Nationwide $2,215 $2,226 $1,999 $2,013 $5,680 $7,325 $2,374 $2,764
Progressive $1,770 $1,661 $1,476 $1,523 $7,985 $8,984 $2,117 $2,189
State Farm $1,643 $1,643 $1,474 $1,474 $5,197 $6,524 $1,912 $2,195
Travelers $1,326 $1,347 $1,311 $1,305 $5,595 $8,804 $1,379 $1,585
USAA $963 $971 $913 $914 $2,966 $3,308 $1,291 $1,397

Free Insurance Comparison

Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

By clicking, you agree to our Terms of Use

Nationwide State Farm Allstate

Minimum Car Insurance in Lancaster, OH

Every driver must carry the minimum car insurance in Lancaster, OH. Take a look at the Ohio car insurance requirements.

Minimum Required Car Insurance Coverage in Lancaster, Ohio

Liability Insurance Required Minimum Coverage Limits Required
Bodily Injury Liability Coverage $25,000 per person
$50,000 per accident
Property Damage Liability Coverage $25,000 minimum

Cheapest Lancaster, OH Car Insurance Rates by Credit Score

Your credit affects car insurance costs in Lancaster, OH. Compare credit history car insurance rates in Lancaster from top companies for good, fair, and poor credit.

Annual Car Insurance Rates by Credit Score in Lancaster, Ohio

Insurance Company Poor Fair Good
Allstate $4,004 $2,917 $2,437
American Family $2,057 $1,403 $1,189
Farmers $3,918 $3,309 $3,151
Geico $2,220 $1,851 $1,483
Liberty Mutual $6,299 $3,857 $3,024
Nationwide $4,013 $3,232 $2,728
Progressive $3,880 $3,363 $3,146
State Farm $3,931 $2,429 $1,914
Travelers $3,168 $2,755 $2,572
USAA $2,069 $1,460 $1,242

Cheapest Lancaster, OH Car Insurance Rates by Driving Record

Your driving record is one of the biggest factors affecting car insurance costs. Compare bad driving record car insurance rates in Lancaster, OH to rates for a clean record with top companies.

Annual Lancaster, Ohio Car Insurance Rates by Driving Record

Group Clean Record With 1 Accident With 1 DUI With 1 Speeding Violation
Allstate $2,622 $3,167 $3,722 $2,967
American Family $1,484 $1,571 $1,571 $1,571
Farmers $2,852 $3,674 $3,583 $3,728
Geico $1,256 $1,814 $2,629 $1,707
Liberty Mutual $3,695 $4,732 $4,840 $4,306
Nationwide $2,663 $3,389 $4,300 $2,945
Progressive $2,984 $4,067 $3,179 $3,622
State Farm $2,509 $3,007 $2,758 $2,758
Travelers $2,091 $2,718 $4,089 $2,428
USAA $1,222 $1,637 $2,149 $1,354

Cheapest Lancaster, OH Car Insurance for Teen Drivers

Teen car insurance in Lancaster, OH can be expensive. Take a look at rates from the top car insurance companies in Lancaster for teenagers.

Annual Car Insurance Rates for Teen Drivers in Lancaster, Ohio

Insurance Company Single 17-Year-Old Female Single 17-Year-Old Male
Allstate $5,783 $6,626
American Family $2,971 $3,231
Farmers $8,110 $8,420
Geico $3,589 $3,339
Liberty Mutual $10,674 $12,059
Nationwide $5,680 $7,325
Progressive $7,985 $8,984
State Farm $5,197 $6,524
Travelers $5,595 $8,804
USAA $2,966 $3,308

Cheapest Lancaster, OH Car Insurance for Seniors

Take a look at Lancaster, OH senior car insurance rates from top companies. Shopping around can make a big difference for senior drivers.

Annual Car Insurance Rates for Senior Drivers in Lancaster, Ohio

Insurance Company Married 60-Year-Old Female Married 60-Year-Old Male
Allstate $1,874 $2,003
American Family $882 $887
Farmers $1,610 $1,699
Geico $1,251 $1,264
Liberty Mutual $1,585 $1,926
Nationwide $1,999 $2,013
Progressive $1,476 $1,523
State Farm $1,474 $1,474
Travelers $1,311 $1,305
USAA $913 $914

Cheapest Lancaster, OH Car Insurance Rates After a DUI

A DUI in Lancaster, OH increases car insurance rates. Compare Lancaster, Ohio DUI car insurance by company to find the cheapest option.

Read more: What are the DUI insurance laws in Ohio?

Annual Car Insurance Rates After a DUI in Lancaster, Ohio

Insurance Company Annual Car Insurance Rates With a DUI
Allstate $3,722
American Family $1,571
Farmers $3,583
Geico $2,629
Liberty Mutual $4,840
Nationwide $4,300
Progressive $3,179
State Farm $2,758
Travelers $4,089
USAA $2,149

Free Insurance Comparison

Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

By clicking, you agree to our Terms of Use

Nationwide State Farm Allstate

Cheapest Lancaster, OH Car Insurance Rates by Commute Length

How does how far you drive affect car insurance rates in Lancaster, OH by commute? Take a look at a comparison of the top companies by commute length.

Annual Car Insurance Rates by Commute Length in Lancaster, Ohio

Insurance Company 10 Mile Commute, 6,000 Annual Mileage 25 Mile Commute, 12,000 Annual Mileage
Allstate $3,119 $3,119
American Family $1,531 $1,568
Farmers $3,459 $3,459
Geico $1,819 $1,883
Liberty Mutual $4,393 $4,393
Nationwide $3,324 $3,324
Progressive $3,463 $3,463
State Farm $2,689 $2,826
Travelers $2,831 $2,831
USAA $1,530 $1,651

The Best Cheap Car Insurance Companies in Lancaster, OH

Take a look at a side-by-side comparison of the top car insurance companies in Lancaster, OH to find the best option for your needs.

Average Annual Car Insurance Rates by Company in Lancaster, Ohio

Insurance Company Average Annual Rates
Allstate $3,119
American Family $1,550
Farmers $3,459
Geico $1,851
Liberty Mutual $4,393
Nationwide $3,324
Progressive $3,463
State Farm $2,758
Travelers $2,831
USAA $1,590

Category Winners: Cheapest Car Insurance in Lancaster, Ohio

Find the cheapest car insurance companies in Lancaster, OH for each category right here.

Best Annual Car Insurance Rates by Company in Lancaster, Ohio

Category Insurance Company
Teenagers American Family
Seniors American Family
Clean Record USAA
With 1 Accident American Family
With 1 DUI American Family
With 1 Speeding Violation USAA

Free Insurance Comparison

Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

By clicking, you agree to our Terms of Use

Nationwide State Farm Allstate

Cheapest Lancaster, OH Car Insurance Rates by Coverage Level

How much coverage you choose will have an impact on your Lancaster car insurance rates. Find the cheapest Lancaster, OH car insurance rates by coverage level.

Annual Car Insurance Rates by Coverage Level in Lancaster, Ohio

Insurance Company Low Medium High
Allstate $3,027 $3,114 $3,218
American Family $1,524 $1,561 $1,563
Farmers $3,275 $3,405 $3,698
Geico $1,793 $1,843 $1,917
Liberty Mutual $4,236 $4,414 $4,530
Nationwide $3,678 $3,222 $3,073
Progressive $3,329 $3,434 $3,626
State Farm $2,621 $2,767 $2,886
Travelers $2,764 $2,868 $2,863
USAA $1,525 $1,589 $1,657

What affects car insurance rates in Lancaster, Ohio?

What factors can have an impact on Lancaster, OH car insurance? There are several reasons why Lancaster car insurance may be different from surrounding cities. Take a look at what affects car insurance rates in Lancaster, Ohio.

Car Theft in Lancaster

High levels of vehicle theft can make car insurance more expensive. Lancaster, OH car theft statistics from the FBI indicate 56 vehicle thefts a year.

Commute Time in Lancaster

The more time you spend in your car the higher the risk of an accident. The average commute length in Lancaster, OH is 26.9 minutes according to City-Data.

Traffic in Lancaster

Traffic and commute times go hand in hand, with more traffic meaning more time on the road. Lancaster, OH traffic data from INRIX ranks Lancaster as the 297th-most congested in the world.

Compare Car Insurance Quotes in Lancaster, OH

Ready to find affordable Lancaster, Ohio car insurance today? Enter your ZIP code for fast, free Lancaster, OH car insurance quotes.

Frequently Asked Questions

How can I compare car insurance rates in Lancaster, OH?

To compare car insurance rates in Lancaster, OH, you can follow these steps:

  1. Research Insurance Companies: Gather a list of insurance companies that provide coverage in Lancaster, OH.
  2. Request Quotes: Contact each insurance company on your list and request a quote for car insurance specific to Lancaster.
  3. Provide Necessary Information: Be prepared to provide information about yourself, your vehicle, and your driving history when requesting quotes.
  4. Compare Quotes: Once you receive quotes from multiple insurers, compare the coverage options, premiums, deductibles, and any additional features or benefits offered.
  5. Consider Coverage Needs: Evaluate your specific coverage needs and choose a policy that offers adequate protection for your vehicle at a price that fits your budget.

What factors can influence car insurance rates in Lancaster, OH?

Several factors can influence car insurance rates in Lancaster, OH. These factors may include:

  • Age and driving experience: Younger and less experienced drivers generally face higher insurance rates compared to older and more experienced drivers.
  • Vehicle make and model: The type of vehicle you own can impact insurance rates. Factors such as the vehicle’s safety features, repair costs, and likelihood of theft can influence premiums.
  • Location: The area where you live in Lancaster, OH, can affect insurance rates. Factors such as crime rates, accident frequency, and population density in the area can influence premiums.
  • Driver’s record: Your driving history, including any accidents, traffic violations, or claims, can affect insurance rates. A clean driving record generally leads to lower premiums.

Are there any discounts available to reduce car insurance rates in Lancaster, OH?

Yes, there may be discounts available to reduce car insurance rates in Lancaster, OH. Some common discounts that may be applicable include:

  • Multi-vehicle discount: Insuring multiple vehicles with the same insurance provider can often lead to a discount on premiums.
  • Good driver discount: If you have a clean driving record with no accidents or violations, you may qualify for a good driver discount.
  • Bundling discounts: If you have other insurance policies, such as homeowners or renters insurance, bundling them with your car insurance from the same provider may result in a discount.
  • Safety features discount: Vehicles equipped with advanced safety features may be eligible for a discount. Check with your insurance company to see which safety features qualify.

Do car insurance rates vary among insurance companies in Lancaster, OH?

Yes, car insurance rates can vary among insurance companies in Lancaster, OH. Each insurance company uses its own formula to calculate rates, considering factors such as your driving profile, vehicle details, and their claims experience. It’s important to compare quotes from multiple insurers to find the best coverage and rates for your specific needs.

Can I change my car insurance policy in Lancaster, OH if I find a better rate?

Yes, you have the option to change your car insurance policy in Lancaster, OH if you find a better rate. Before making any changes, review the terms and conditions of your current policy, including any cancellation fees or potential gaps in coverage. It’s also recommended to reach out to your current insurer to discuss any concerns or potential discounts they may offer to retain your business.

What are the minimum car insurance requirements in Lancaster, OH?

In Lancaster, OH, the minimum car insurance requirements are:

  • $25,000 bodily injury liability coverage per person
  • $50,000 bodily injury liability coverage per accident
  • $25,000 property damage liability coverage per accident

Can I customize my car insurance coverage in Lancaster, OH?

Yes, you can customize your car insurance coverage in Lancaster, OH to suit your needs. In addition to the mandatory liability coverage, you have the option to add additional coverage types such as collision, comprehensive, uninsured/underinsured motorist, medical payments, and roadside assistance. Customizing your coverage allows you to enhance your protection and tailor it to your specific requirements.

Get a FREE Quote in Minutes

Insurance rates change constantly — we help you stay ahead by making it easy to compare top options and save.

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

By clicking, you agree to our Terms of Use

Nationwide State Farm Allstate
Liberty MutualFarmers InsuranceNationwideState Farm