Free Car Insurance Comparison
Secured with SHA-256 Encryption
UPDATED: Mar 5, 2020
It’s all about you. We want to help you make the right coverage choices.
Advertiser Disclosure: We strive to help you make confident insurance decisions. Comparison shopping should be easy. We partner with top insurance providers. This doesn't influence our content. Our opinions are our own.
Editorial Guidelines: We are a free online resource for anyone interested in learning more about auto insurance. Our goal is to be an objective, third-party resource for everything auto insurance related. We update our site regularly, and all content is reviewed by auto insurance experts.
“Life’s like a road that you travel on,
When there’s one day here and the next day gone…”
A motor vehicle accident can end your life without warning in a matter of seconds.
Americans spend an average of 17,600 minutes driving each year, and every 12 minutes a person is killed in a car accident on our nation’s roads.
Car accidents happen everywhere, but some of the roads in our country are proving to be much more dangerous than others.
Click here to review our methodology.
The 10 States with the Most Dangerous Highways
With 1.3 million people dying in traffic accidents each year and that death count on the rise, we have a serious safety concern on our hands.
That’s why our researchers compiled over 8,500 data points using the leading resources: NHSTA “crashstats,” FARS totals, the reports published by the U.S. DOT and FHWA, as well as the IIHS “Fatality Facts” to see what’s causing all these unnecessary deaths in our country.
All 50 states and the District of Columbia were ranked according to six complex, statistic-based factors explained in detail here.
#10 – Texas
Austin’s Pennybacker Bridge
Best Ranking: Highway Bridges – 11th
Worst Ranking: Speeding Deaths – 47th
Texas’ nickname and state flag represent pride, defiance, and independence. The problem is when Texas residents defy the law risking the safety of others.
Like Ian Johnson admits from behind bars in this video: “It’s not worth it. Just for that 10 second rush. It’s not worth it.”
With 1,105 people killed due to speeding in 2015 alone, Texas drivers need to slow down and find other means to illustrate their independence.
#9 – Colorado
Tunnel at Colorado National Monument
Best Ranking: Death Rate – 19th
Worst Ranking: Federal Funding – 41st
Over a decade ago, Colorado’s transportation situation was considered a “quiet crisis.”
Ranking in the worst half of the U.S. for speeding deaths, failing to wear seat belts, unsafe highway bridges, number of fatal crashes, and lack of federal funding.
Colorado’s crisis is far from a quiet one today. According to The Denver Post, “Declining revenues coupled with booming population growth has put the state’s motorists on a collision course with potholes and congestion.”
Hopefully Colorful Colorado will invest the necessary greenbacks so the colors it’s known for don’t include bloodshed on its neglected highways.
#8 – Massachusetts
Boston’s Zakim Bunker Hill Bridge
Best Ranking: Death Rate – 2nd
Worst Ranking (Tie): Highway Bridges & Federal Funding – 50th
Massachusetts ranks in the top three worst states in America for failing to wear seat belts, having unsafe highway bridges, and for getting insufficient federal funding.
While many states gets half of their highway spending from federal aid, Massachusetts only gets 21.5 percent, which means there isn’t much hope for all those unsafe roadways.
Fortunately despite this lack of funding, the Bay State has managed to keep traffic fatalities at bay. Massachusetts had 306 people killed in car crashes out of its 6.8 million residents, which was the lowest death rate for any state—beat only by D.C.
#6 (Tie) – West Virginia
Sunrise over Downtown Charleston
Best Ranking: Federal Funding – 8th
Worst Ranking: Fatal Crashes – 44th
Comparing West Virginia and Massachusetts’ dangerous highways prove that money doesn’t solve all problems.
Since 2011, West Virginia has gotten an annual average of 25 cents per resident in federal funding for highway improvements, which makes Massachusetts’ nine cents a person average, seem like a bad joke.
Sadly, the $2.3 million the government deposited into West Virginia’s highway trust fund from 2011-2015 didn’t stop the 1,548 people from being killed in car crashes those very same years.
The Mountain State’s problems don’t end there. West Virginia is ranked in the worst half of the U.S. for interstate speeding deaths (37th), failure to wear seat belts (26th), poor highway bridges (32nd), and its per capita death rate (43rd).
#6 (Tie) – Montana
Glendive’s Makoshika State Park
Best Ranking: Federal Funding – 4th
Worst Ranking: Death Rate – 50th
Montana gets even more help than West Virginia from the federal government with maintaining its highways.
Ranked 48th in the U.S. for not wearing seat belts, Montana residents aren’t doing their part to keep themselves safe either. Which is why the Montana MythCrashers made a funny, yet inspirational video with the message: “Seat belts are as important as life itself.”
Hopefully , Montana residents will take that lesson to heart, because like he explains in the video:
“There’s no way you’re going to be able to brace yourself in an accident. At just 35 mph you’ll be hitting at the same force as if you jumped off a four story building.”
#5 – North Carolina
Highway leading to NC State University
Best Ranking: Fatal Crashes – 17th
Worst Ranking: Federal Funding – 44th
Receiving only 10 cents per resident in 2015 federal aid towards its highway spending, the Tar Heel state isn’t getting the help it needs to maintain safe public roads.
- NCDOT Now – weekly video publications communicating with residents about new traffic laws and road improvements being made.
- School Bus Cameras – automated devices are installed on North Carolina school buses to catch drivers passing stopped school buses. These tickets cost a minimum of $400!
- NC Vision Zero – an initiative to eliminate traffic deaths and injuries in North Carolina. Take the vision zero pledge here.
- Booze it & Lose It – a 23-year-old campaign aimed at stopping drunk driving especially around Labor Day, which has had great success with alcohol-related highway deaths—down 23 percent since 2016.
- BeSmarterThanThat.com – a website created by the NCDOT dedicated to keeping those impaired by alcohol out of the driver seat. This site makes it easy to establish a designated driver in advance or quickly find a ride home after drinking. It also includes videos and posts explaining why drinking and driving is never worth it.
- Obey the Sign or Pay the Fine – an annual speed enforcement blitz taking place for a couple weeks around Easter with increased patrols and a zero tolerance for speeding.
The main reason North Carolina landed on our Worst Driver Top 10 was because of speeding, and ranking 41st with 547 total speeding fatalities in this study, it remains a major problem across the state.
Hopefully North Carolina residents will heed all the laws and warnings their dedicated department of transportation has put in place.
#4 – Pennsylvania
Bridges at Downtown Pittsburgh
Best Ranking: Death Rate – 22nd
Worst Ranking: Highway Bridges – 46th
The primary reason Pennsylvania, the Keystone State, has ranked in the top four states with the Most Dangerous Highways (two years in-a-row!) is because of its unsafe bridges.
This is ironic considering the meaning behind its nickname:
“A keystone is a central wedge in an arch that locks all other pieces of an arch in place. It is the part of an arch that all other parts depend upon.”
Every year since 2011, Pennsylvania has had at least 37 percent of its highway bridges rated as deficient by the Federal Highway Administration.
The Keystone State seems to be missing some highway bridge keystones.
Even Pennsylvania’s best ranking factor in our study (Death Rate: 22nd) has great need for improvement. On average, an alarming 1,240 people have been killed on this state’s public roads every year since 2011.
#3 – Arizona
O’Callaghan/Tillman Bridge over the Hoover Dam
Best Ranking: Highway Bridges – 9th
Worst Ranking (Tie): Speeding Deaths & Fatal Crashes – 45th
Tragically, Arizona’s two factors that make its highways some of the most dangerous in the U.S. both involve highest number of deaths.
As you can see in the graphic Arizona police chase footage above, crashes that involve speeding greatly intensify the sustained injuries and risk of death.
Most of the drivers in the Grand Canyon State aren’t fleeing officers and cruising on the wrong side of the road while also speeding, but what we all need to remember is that speeding alone is enough to cause a horrific crash that kills people.
On a more positive note, only 11 percent of Arizona’s bridges were determined deficient in 2015.
Click here to enjoy a fascinating time lapse video of the Hoover Dam Bypass Bridge (pictured above) being built from 2006 to 2010.
#2 – South Carolina
Ashley River Bridges leading to Downtown Charleston
Best Ranking: Seat Belt Use – 20th
Worst Ranking: Death Rate – 47th
Our study revealed major safety concerns for the Palmetto State that are much scarier than the cockroach who invades homes in this state and even has the same name.
South Carolina is ranked in the top 10 worst states for three major categories:
- Fatal Crashes – 43rd
- Speeding Deaths – 46th
- Death Rate – 47th
In 2015 alone, South Carolina had 977 total people killed in traffic accidents, and 361 (37 percent) of those deaths were caused by a driver who was speeding. This is a rate of 20 people killed in car crashes for every 100,000 residents.
It’s wonderful that from 2011 to 2015 an average of 89.96 percent of South Carolina residents wore their seat belts.
The devastating reality is that seat belts can’t solve South Carolina’s deadly highway problems. The data shows that despite South Carolinian’s dedication to buckling up over the years, people are still dying on these roads at astronomical rates.
#1 – Louisiana
Downtown Shreveport over the Red River