Free Car Insurance Comparison
Secured with SHA-256 Encryption
Call for FREE quotes: (855) 425-8122
UPDATED: Sep 10, 2019
It’s all about you. We want to help you make the right coverage choices.
We strive to help you make confident insurance decisions. Comparison shopping should be easy. We partner with top insurance providers. This doesn't influence our content. Our opinions are our own.
Drinking and driving make for an incredibly deadly combo.
The risk of death by car accident is over eleven times greater for drivers impaired by alcohol.
And, if you don’t value your own life enough to swap for a soda or catch a ride, you have to at least consider all the innocent people you are putting in danger on the roads around you.
According to MADD, “In 2016, 10,497 people died in drunk driving crashes – one every 50 minutes – and 290,000 were injured in drunk driving crashes”
Or maybe money motivates you. Drunk driving accidents, injuries, and deaths on average are costing every American adult over $500 and the U.S. as a whole $132 billion each and every year!
This is quite possibly the costliest, deadliest problem our country has ever faced. Read on to see which ten states are in the most trouble.
Click here for our detailed methodology.
The 10 Deadliest States for Drunk Driving
#10 – Texas
Best Ranking Factor: DUI Arrests – 35th
Worst Ranking Factor: DUI Fatalities – 9th
Of the total car crash deaths in Texas in 2016, 1,670 – 44 percent – of them involved an alcohol-impaired driver.
Thankfully, the Lonestar State is trying to corral its drunk drivers.
In 2016, there was an impressive total of 68,371 DUI arrests made in Texas.
As you can see in the below news report, even Texas judges who beg for leniency are getting arrested for drinking and driving.
Hopefully the extra efforts from law enforcement make a difference, because according to our studies, the public roadways in Texas are some of the deadliest in America.
Texas has ranked in the top five states every year since 2011 for having the worst drivers in the country.
#9 – New Mexico
Best Ranking Factor: DUI Arrests – 29th
Worst Ranking Factor: DUI Death Cost – 6th
Like its neighbor, Texas, New Mexico is working to stop drunk drivers, ranking in the better half of the U.S. for its number of DUI arrests.
However, the families of the 148 people killed on New Mexico roads in 2016 by drivers impaired by alcohol must feel this is far from enough.
Residents of this “Land of Enchantment” aren’t just paying in deaths and injuries for this selfish behavior either.
Each New Mexico state resident is paying an average of $223.45 every year in taxes to help cover the cost of drunk driving fatalities.
This must be extremely disenchanting for the over two million people living in this state.
#7 (Tie) – Nebraska
Best Ranking Factor: DUI Death Cost – 34th
Worst Ranking Factor: DUI Arrests – 5th
You can’t live “the good life” if you’re killed by a drunk driver or put in prison for being a drunk-driving murderer.
Nebraska’s strengths and weaknesses are the exact opposite of New Mexico’s.
Far too many Nebraska drivers are getting away with being drunk behind the wheel considering 38 percent of all the 2016 traffic deaths in this state involved a driver impaired by booze.
The scariest part? Nebraska was ranked 26th on this countdown last year . . . talk about a huge jump in the wrong direction!
#7 (Tie) – Idaho
Best Ranking Factor: DUI Death Cost – 25th
Worst Ranking Factor: DUI Laws – 3rd
Unfortunately, Idaho’s best ranking factor comes from the fact that state residents are paying $165.17 a year in taxes due to their drunk drivers.
The Gem State isn’t putting a high enough value to all its treasures considering its lax drunk driving laws.
Thanks to insufficient laws, Idaho has 4th DUI offenders caught driving, blowing three times the legal limit. It’s a good thing these teen “heroes” where there to help:
Thankfully this story has a good ending, but it isn’t safe for teens to be following and filming a drunk driver around as she takes out mailboxes and nearly causes car crashes.
Idaho drunk drivers need to be stopped long before it gets to this treacherous point.
#6 – Rhode Island
Best Ranking Factor: DUI Arrests – 33rd
Worst Ranking Factor: DUI Laws – 3rd
Although it’s the smallest state in America, Rhode Island is still making a big impact when it comes to deadly drunk driving in our country.
Little Rhody might be making a good amount of DUI arrests, which equaled over 10 percent of the total arrests in 2016, but the arrests themselves aren’t going to do any good without laws to back them up.
Hopefully, Rhode Island officials realize the dangers of drunk driving and take action to strengthen their state laws soon.
#5 – Maine
Best Ranking Factor: DUI Penalties – 38th
Worst Ranking Factor: DUI Fatalities – 4th
Thankfully, Maine takes drunk driving seriously with a Zero Tolerance law and penalties that come from both the state courts and the Bureau of Motor Vehicles including suspended licence, mandatory ignition interlock device, driver’s education courses, fines, and possible jail time.
Regrettably, these drunk driving penalties weren’t enough to keep this 23-year-old from being struck and killed by a repeat drunk driving offender:
Jumping from 10th place to 5th in under a year, Maine is quickly headed in the wrong direction in regards to drunk driving.
#4 – Montana
Best Ranking Factor: DUI Penalties – 40th
Worst Ranking Factor (Tie): DUI Death Cost & DUI Laws – 1st
It’s pretty sad that the state landing in 5th last year and one spot higher this year, wins 1st place for the worst in the U.S. for not just one, but TWO drunk driving categories.
Montana residents pay the highest amount in the entire country – a whopping $431.65 each year in taxes – to help cover the cost of all the drunk driving deaths in their state.
Plus, “The Treasure State” has the most lenient drunk driving laws and statutes in the entire country with no sobriety checkpoints and lax or non-existent laws regarding ignition interlock devices, license revocation, and refusing a breathalyzer.
#3 – South Dakota
Best Ranking Factor: DUI Penalties – 48th
Worst Ranking Factor: DUI Arrests – 1st
South Dakotans must feel it’s so unlikely to get arrested for drunk driving, that it’s worth the risk.
The DUI penalties in South Dakota might be on the strict side, ranking in the top five for that category, but these penalties aren’t always enforced.
For example, when Scott Larson got his 9th DUI, instead of 10 years in prison he got 18-24 months in a court program thanks to some good ole South Dakota mercy:
It’s even legal in “The Mount Rushmore State” to sell alcohol to someone who is only 18 years old as long as they are with a parent, guardian, or spouse over the age of 21.
#2 – North Dakota
Best Ranking Factor: DUI Penalties – 18th
Worst Ranking Factor (Tie): DUI Death Cost & DUI Arrests – 2nd
Sadly, North Dakota not only ranks in the worst half of the U.S. for all five of the categories in this drunk driving study, but it also ranks a top ten worst state in three of the five categories.
North Dakota state residents pay $399.76 annually to cover the cost of drunk driving deaths in their state.
It’s good that the North Dakota police force is catching drunk drivers, but it’s clearly a problem when 17.66 percent of all the arrests taking place in the state are for drunk driving.
Considering it has ranked in the top five for being one of deadliest states for drunk driving four years in a row now, we really hope that “The Peace Garden State” starts waging war against its drunk drivers.
#1 – Wisconsin
Best Ranking Factor: DUI Death Cost – 31st
Worst Ranking Factor: DUI Penalties – 3rd
Thanks to its excessively high number of drunk driving deaths and DUI arrests and due to having some of the most lenient drunk driving laws and penalties, Wisconsin has earned the title: Deadliest State for Drunk Driving.
As you can see in the below CBS report, Wisconsin is the only state in America to not criminalize 1st time drinking and driving offenders.
“People know the first offense is a slap on the wrist,” addressing the issue Wisconsin Senator, Chris Larson says, “it’s a moving violation.”
With some of the shortest license suspensions for drunk driving, cheapest DUI fines in the country, and sobriety checkpoints being prohibited by the state, Wisconsin is clearly not doing enough to stop drunk drivers.
LifeSafer says, “In every class, there are star students and laggards, and so is it with anti-DUI efforts. Some states do everything they can to address the issue of drinking and driving. And some states are, well, Wisconsin.”
Ranking 4th, 3rd, 2nd, and now 1st for having the most dangerous roads in the U.S. due to drunk drivers, The Badger State needs to make some big changes (and fast) to make roads safer for all those who live there.
Trends and Highlights
View the interactive graphics here.
Seven of the 10 states from our countdown landed on this deadliest list last year:
Six of the 10 states on this deadliest list had their worst ranking factors land in the top three for the entire country:
- Idaho: DUI Laws – 3rd
- Rhode Island: DUI Laws – 3rd
- Montana: DUI Death Cost & DUI Laws – 1st
- South Dakota: DUI Arrests – 1st
- North Dakota: DUI Death Cost & DUI Arrests – 2nd
- Wisconsin: DUI Penalties – 3rd
Lenient drunk driving laws and far too many traffic deaths caused by drunk drivers are two of the biggest reasons the above ten states landed on this list.
Not once did DUI Laws or DUI Death Rank come up as best ranking factors.
The most common worst ranking factors were DUI Death Cost, DUI Arrests, and DUI Laws, each showing up three times on our deadliest list this year.
Drive Safe and SOBER!
NEVER driving while impaired by alcohol is the key to end drunk driving, but you can take it a step further and learn ways to spot drunk drivers and alert the cops.
Here are the top ten things drunk drivers do behind the wheel:
When your plans involve alcohol, here are some tips to keep yourself and all those around you safe:
Drinkinganddriving.org says, “Since the September 11 terror attacks, over 200,000 men women and children have died in America as a result of drunk driving . . . It is time to stand up and admit that as a culture, we drink together and LET each other drive away.”
The rankings for this comprehensive drunk driving study came from the most up-to-date reports from the following leading resources:
- National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA)
- Mothers Against Drunk Driving (MADD)
- The FBI’s Department of Justice
- State-specific DOT statutes
- Governors Highway Safety Association
United States Census Bureau
All 50 states plus D.C. received a final score based on five main categories that each had its own intricate calculation:
- DUI Death Rank – a total score derived from two rankings:
- DUI Death Cost – a total score derived from three rankings:
- DUI Arrests – a total score derived from five rankings:
- DUI Penalties – a total score derived from three rankings:
- DUI Laws – a score based on five components:
For each category, the highest rankings were awarded to the worst states in the country.
The higher a state ranked in each category, the lower final score it received.
Lowest Scores = Deadliest States for Drunk Driving
Our study implemented weighted measures to demonstrate the impact each manifestation of a category can have on a person, community, and state. Each weight is representative of the severity of the category.
|Cost per Fatality by State||10.00|
|Types of Laws and Statutes||10.00|
These weighted scores are necessary to deduce the most dangerous state. The final rankings, which determines the worst state, are not perfectly correlated with the final scores of the non-weighted rankings, which determines the worst state per category.
Complete Rankings: Most Dangerous States for Drunk Driving (Weighted + Unweighted Tables)
– To view and sort the table by category, click on header columns.
– Click the box to expand the table for weighted and unweighted rankings
For all media inquiries, please email: Joshua Barnes
|STATE||FATALITY (WEIGHTED RANK)||COST PER FATALITY (WEIGHTED RANK)||DUI ARRESTS (WEIGHTED RANK)||DUI PENALTIES (WEIGHTED RANK)||TYPES OF LAWS/STATUTES (WEIGHTED RANK)||TOTAL SCORE||RANK|
|District of Columbia||0.35||1.50||12.75||3.60||2.70||20.90||20|
|STATE||FATALITY RANK||COST PER FATALITY RANK||DUI ARRESTS||DUI PENALTIES||TYPES OF LAWS/STATUTES||TOTAL SCORE||RANK|
|District of Columbia||1||15||51||18||27||112||20|