Most Reputable Companies for Car Insurance

FREE Car Insurance Comparison

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Compare quotes from the top car insurance companies and save!

Here's what you need to know...

  • Geico provides insurance in all 50 states, and the company has been around for more than 70 years
  • Nationwide started out offering auto insurance to Ohio farmers and ranchers in 1926, and has grown to offer insurance nationwide to drivers of all professions
  • Liberty Mutual began as a workers compensation insurance company in 1912

When looking for car insurance, it is a good idea to shop around for the best rates and coverage. You can request price quotes from several companies using an online insurance quote comparison website.

Going with the absolute cheapest car insurance quote isn’t always the best idea. You also want to make sure that the car insurance company is reputable.

Here are 10 of the most reputable insurance companies, based on customer ratings and the Insurance Information Institute. Companies are listed in no particular order.

Enter your zip code above and we will help you find insurance from the most reputable car insurance companies.

Geico

Geico provides insurance in all 50 states, and the company has been around for more than 70 years. Geico ranks very high in response and repair, benefits and discounts, policy flexibility, customer service and claims timeliness.

Geico offers several discounts to its policyholders, including good driver, good student, anti-theft device, multiple-vehicle, multiple-line, corporate loyalty, loyalty, and advanced safety features car insurance discounts.

Geico is one of the most affordable insurance companies because they operate through a non-agent model, which allows for policyholders who file claims and inquiries by phone and online, reducing overhead costs.

FREE Car Insurance Comparison

Compare quotes from the top car insurance companies and save!

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Progressive

Progressive has been a leader in the industry for more than 70 years. The company consistently receives top marks for its response, repair, and timeliness for customer service and claims.

Progressive policyholders can receive discounts such as good student, corporate affiliate, loyalty, advanced safety features, low-mileage, multiple-vehicle, anti-theft device, full payment and automatic payment discounts.

We have a list and more detailed explanation of Progressive car insurance discounts.

Progressive stands out because of its concierge level of claims service and its immediate response vehicles, which provide quick and easy claims services.

Esurance

adobestock_18298693-1600x1600

Esurance does not have the 70 years of experience that some other car insurance companies have, but the company has quickly made a name for itself in the industry since it was launched in December 1994.

Aside from its hassle-free policy-purchasing process and expedited claims processing, the company is known for its environmental initiatives.

Esurance consciously limits its paper consumption and takes steps to mitigate the effects of carbon dioxide pollution. We have a full list of Esurance car insurance discounts, check it out to make a more informed decision when choosing which car insurance companies to go with.

Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company

adobestock_56525394-1600x1600

Nationwide started out offering auto insurance to Ohio farmers and ranchers in 1926, and has grown to offer insurance nationwide to drivers of all professions.

The company receives top marks for customer service and claims timeliness, and stands out for its 100 percent guarantees on repairs for the life of the policyholder’s car.

Policyholders can take advantage of many discounts, including anti-theft device, advanced safety features, loyalty, good driver, good student, multiple-line, multiple-vehicle, and corporate affiliate discounts.

See the car insurance coverage and deductible options Nationwide offers.

State Farm Mutual

adobestock_117541441-1600x1600

State Farm is another insurance company that started by offering auto insurance to a limited pool of farmer policyholders in 1922.

The company went on to expand its offerings to policyholders of all sorts and has become a large and reputable company.

The company consistently receives good marks in response and repair, customer service and claims timeliness, policy flexibility, benefits, and discounts. For more information on this company see our State Farm car insurance review.

Liberty Mutual Holding Co.

AdobeStock_51154930-1600x1600

Liberty Mutual began as a workers compensation insurance company in 1912. The company then branched out to offer auto insurance in 1914.

The company is well known for its policy features including cracked windshield repair and Total Liberty Care Facilities to take care of repairs quickly.

While the company receives high marks for its policy offerings, its customer service is lacking. To find out more about this company head over to our Liberty Mutual car insurance review.

Allstate Corp.

AdobeStock_76267159-1600x1600

Allstate was founded in 1931 and started the first auto insurance company that offered policies by direct mail. The company also provided policies through the Sears catalog.

Allstate rates well among companies for their policy flexibility, but the company’s timeliness for customer service and claims misses the mark sometimes.

The company does stand out among the many insurance providers by offering deductible discounts for each year that the policyholder goes without any accidents. There are a lot of benefits for choosing Allstate car insurance.

USAA Insurance Group

adobestock_74392503-1600x1600

United Services Automobile Association (USAA) started out in 1922 by offering automobile insurance to U.S. Army officers. At the time, this group had a difficult time receiving automobile insurance because the group was viewed as a high risk.

Today, USAA offers insurance policies to all Armed Forces members and those who served in the U.S. Armed Forces honorably.

The policies are also available to their immediate families. USAA stands out because of its extensive discounts and benefits. Read the list of USAA discounts to find out which ones you would qualify for.

Farmers Insurance Group

adobestock_91691614-1600x1600-1

Farmers Insurance was founded in 1928 to offer lower insurance premiums to farmers and ranchers. The company has since expanded its customer base and has become the third most popular provider of private passenger automobile insurance in the United States.

Today, the company is reputable for its good driver discounts and customized policies. They have also become famous for their Farmers fast quote service.

AAA

adobestock_29502489-1600x1600

American Automobile Association (AAA) is a very popular not-for-profit organization that offers a wide range of services, including automobile insurance.

The insurance is not comprehensive, but it does provide savings by allowing members services such as towing and roadside assistance from their primary automobile insurance policies.

Aside from the excellent roadside assistance and AAA-approved automobile repair facilities, membership offers many additional benefits such as discounts for travel and retail. For a better understanding of how AAA works, read our AAA review for car insurance.

There are many reputable automobile insurance companies and policies to choose from, but the only way to find the policy that is best for you is to do some price shopping.

Use our car insurance comparison tool and enter your zip code to find the best car insurance for your needs.

FREE Car Insurance Comparison

Compare quotes from the top car insurance companies and save!

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

[0-9]
[0-9]