While nobody can really tell you which of these companies is best for everybody, it might be possible to compare Geico vs State Farm to decide which insurer will be the best choice for you.
Is State Farm or Geico Larger?
It might be interesting to compare the size of these two insurance giants. State Farm is a larger company, and it commands a bigger share of the insurance market.
- State Farm Market Share: About 19%
- Geico Market Share: About 11%
- State Farm Premiums Earned: About $30.5 Billion
- Geico Premiums Earned: About $20.5 Billion
Which Insurance Company Do Customers Like Better?
You cannot always just look at overall company ratings to figure out which insurer will please you more. Your experience could depend upon your individual agent, local claims office, and many other factors.
However, it is interesting to look at recent consumer ratings of these two companies.
J.D. Power is a large market research firm that conducts surveys to find out how customers like different companies.
When J.D. Power asked consumers about their overall experience with State Farm, the average rating was 3.5 out of 5 stars.
When asked about Geico, customers rated it only 2.5 out of 5 stars. It is important to note that customers seemed more satisfied with Geico’s pricing and coverage. Customers favored State Farm when it came to their billing process and ease of contacting the insurer.
How are Geico and State Farm Different?
This might suggest that Geico tends to offer cheaper policies with adequate coverage, but State Farm might focus more on customer service than on price competitiveness.
It is true that State Farm relies more on a national network of local insurance agents. You can find Geico agents in some areas, but this company relies a lot more on direct phone and internet sales.
You might decide if you are comfortable buying and handling your insurer over the internet, or you would prefer to work with a local agent.
You might also decide if you would rather pay a bit more to make sure it is easy to get an agent on the phone when you need to ask a question, change your policy, or make a claim.
Is State Farm or Geico Cheaper?
Your age, location, driving history, type of vehicle, and several other factors will be considered before either company offers you a premium. The only way to find the cheapest premium and best coverage is to compare policy quotes for your own vehicles.